Not too long ago, Mr. Colbert had an interesting episode regarding Obama's proposal to extend school days and possibly abolish summer vacation. The humorous piece got everyone talking. Take a look for yourself.
I loved how he brought a 5th grader to the show to further stress his point. (I am a big fan of Colbert.) I couldn't think of a better way to better express the argument.
Sure its obvious no one wants a longer school day and no summer vacations. All work, no play equals really bad days! What do we have to look forward to? What about the TripCrazed content! Oh no!
All jokes aside, I think it would be pretty hard to make huge changes overnight. There are a lot of circumstances to consider and it would just awful.
How do you feel about the points made about a longer school day and no summer vacation? How would you be affected?
Comments (6)
I would just like to give that kid a shout out for not flinching once despite all the audience outbursts except for cracking a minor smile at the end. Otherwise, I think things would be better with no summer vacation. There would probably still be breaks throughout the year when children could have small vacations. My cousins in India went to school all year round and not only are they very smart, but their high school ended when they were 15, so they started college that year. Ultimately, it would just save kids time to do things during those best years of your life:your early 20's.
Adding another grading period in the summer would make sense; then putting a week or so in between grading periods . . . something like that would definitely improve education while giving school kids a chance to recharge and be kids.
Ha! Well nobody tells you how long it takes to get you through college! =P
Let them suckers learn early.
I feel that extending the school year (even though its gonna suck cuz I'm going to be a teacher) would be the best idea. I'm for extending the day but no later than 4 really, that's a bit much.
We are virtually one of the only countries that has such a long gap between school years, and as a result we are low in the running for most educated students.
I feel that bringing end of one year and the beginning of another a little closer together would allow for the students to retain more information and to also be able to dedicate more time for lessons so teachers don't put all this weight on them at the end of the year to finish things they didn't sooner.
It wasn't too long ago that I was in public school, and what I remember isn't ending the school year with tons of material left unfinished, or running out of time during class. No, what I remember is a lot of wasted time. I remember waking up and wishing it was okay to skip school because I knew I wasn't going to be doing anything in class that day besides doing homework in class and watching movies. We don't spend nearly as much time in class during college as we did in K-12, our breaks are longer, and we learn a hell of a lot more. If there is something so fundamentally flawed with our education system, why don't we try fixing it instead of just overwhelming children with what we already have?
Not to mention that this would either a) make it impossible for families to go on vacation together, b) force them to go at one of about 3 times during the year, making it ungodly expensive because short breaks are when rates are highest, or c) force families to take their children out of school in order to go on vacation. I think it's absurd to expect people will chose the first option, economically asinine to expect them to take the second option, and utterly counterproductive to the supposed motive to have nearly all kids missing school for at least one week every single year, not even including absences due to illness, doctor's appointments, etc.
Doing away with summer break would also make it impossible for kids to get a job before they're 18, something that just doesn't make sense. We're going to make the legal age to drive 16, but ensure that the only people who can afford to drive are either kids with rich and spoiling parents or kids who've been saving up their allowance since birth? How are children supposed to learn the value of money, the pride of being able to buy things through your own hard work?
Do we actually expect kids to pay attention and sit at a desk for 8 hours straight? I'm predicting more skipping, more sleeping in class, more disruptive behavior. And that's not even including the students who know exactly how and where they've been screwed.
What about everything we're expected to do outside of school? Extracurricular involvement or volunteering are nearly mandatory for colleges these days. Sometimes I didn't get home from my activities until 9 anyway; how is this going to work with longer school days? Kids in high school are learning to drive, but when are they going to have the time for 50 hours of supervised driving and all the other requirements for getting a license?
How are we supposed to do our homework and study? This might actually impede progress. Kids are already tired when they come home from school, now they won't have any time to rest before starting homework and they'll still be up late working on it.
Not to mention, if we're going to have school during the summer, it's going to cost a fortune. We'll have to equip tons of schools with air-conditioning, and we'll have to pay summer salaries for everyone who helps run the school-- that includes teachers, janitors, administrative staff, bus drivers, lunch ladies, you name it. Additionally, since teachers don't make that much during the year, many of them work a second job during the summer. This would put an end to that, and any extra money they might be making by working full-time. Speaking of the things we'd be putting an end to by cutting out summer vacation, what about summer school? When will we have sessions to help students who are falling behind? Or is the plan that, once we implement this new system, there simply won't be anyone who needs those types of sessions?
More points later, probably.
I think we should have longer school days and have school all year. we would retain more information, and children/teens/young adults would get more frequent breaks instead of a large gap in the school year and instead of taking jobs away we would be creating more because schools would need more teachers, aids, lucheons, etc. When talking about daycare and summercamp, who cares? parents wouldn't have to spend the extra money because kids would be in school, isn't that a good thing? working parents would also not have to worry about their children after school either because if the school hours are extended a little they can pick up their kids after work.
It's time to change our educational system, i'm in college and it's shitty which is another topic all together. the transition wouldn't affect me because i am graduating but it would affect my future children and i want them to be very intelligent. we fail compared to everyone else and it is true, in america what you earn is more important than what you learn and that's why we have shows like the hills, know more about tiger woods affiars than global warming and that's why most of us are morons.
i'm in favor of any change to the educational system, Asia does it, why can't we?