Monday, 18 May 2009
-
Which World is Better?
I'm currently reading a book called "Don't Know Much About Geography," which, despite being written for eejits has actually got me thinking lots about the world. Today, it reminded me of sitting in a geography lesson when I was about 10, and being shown two maps. Both of the world.
It didn't make sense to us as a class of ten-year-olds why Asia should have to be sliced down the middle so that America could claim central position. It didn't make sense that the International date line should appear as an unseemly squiggle across the near-center of the page, to fuel Americaphilla.
We thought, and I still think, that the map familiar to Brits looks more correct. And not because "Our country is in the middle! Therefore it must be right!" but because the British map doesn't show a complete disregard for the Greenwich Meridian, from which standard time is calculated. And because on our maps everything known to us as "the West" is in the West. And everything known as "the East" is in the East.
I always felt the British map looks tidier. I find it more aesthetically pleasing.
I'm also aware that I probably only hold these views because the British map is the one I'm familiar with and have grown up with.
Which map are you more familiar with? Do American maps generally involve America taking center stage? Which map do you think is better? What do other country maps look like?
Post a Comment
- Back to tripcrazed's Tripcrazed Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in tripcrazed's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)














Comments (11)
the maps i see usually don't have america as the center piece.
I don't understand what you're talking about. The british world map? I Googled that and it looks no different from the world map that I've seen my whole entire life. Can you explain to me exactly what you mean?
I know the maps in south america (or at least in this one school I saw in Argentina) had the map completely flipped upside down with South facing up and Noth down and everything was where it needed to be. but the reason for this is because they are a coutnry far far south. Here is an example:
http://lh3.ggpht.com/_n9DGA9Surj4/SJJP0-FpVAI/AAAAAAAAAQ0/LWek8Jx7ZtE/Upsidedown+Map+Of+The+World--Optimized.JPG
Let me know if that worked.
I think it is an interesting perspective because it is one we'd normaly not think about. ^_^
I've never seen one with America in the center, but we have two and one has Britain centered and the other has the Pacific centered.
Personally, I think the one with Britain centered is better because it's easier for me to distinguish between timezones [having Greenwich centered and all] and yeah, it's tidier.
I don't really mind though, a map is a map.
the map on a globe... there is a center that cannot be seen, cyclic, + the perfect shape: O,
I don't think the American-style map is that common...
havent seen many maps to know the difference.
Most of the maps I've seen just have the US on the left side, not centralized (like in the picture above). Once in a while, I'll see the Pacific Ocean in the center of a flat map.
I totally agree. All of the maps that I've seen, though (being a native to America), are the kind you described - The Prime Meridian in the middle, and Great Britain obviously accompanying it.
I've never seen a world map with America in the center. There's no reason for it to be there.
I use the Thomas Guide which just has the map of cities.
I think the American one is more colorful so I like it better :P