Wednesday, 06 May 2009
-
All Inclusive Resorts-All the Rave or Overrated?
I have had experiences staying in all kinds of lodging while traveling. I have been in hostels, sketchy hotels or just plain crummy hotels (ice cold water showers are no fun no matter what country you're in), luxury hotels with private balconies and round the clock concierge service, condominiums,
campsites, and more, including one trip to the Jersey Shore where we lived out of and slept in my car (yes this was free, but we did get a ticket from the Stone Harbor Police Department. Apparently, it's illegal to sleep in your car in Jersey. Who knew?)
On two of my vacations, one to Jamaica and the other to Cozumel, I have stayed at all-inclusive resorts. All-inclusive vacations can be great. The benefits can include paying one flat rate for your lodging, meals, drinks (usually including alcoholic beverages), and some activities, like snorkeling, games, activities for kids, arts and crafts, entertainment at night, dance lessons, cooking demonstrations, and exercise classes. Other perks can include free transportation to and from the airport to your accommodations. Additionally, all-inclusive resorts usually bring high volumes of visitors to the country, while also providing jobs to the local community within the resort.
However, all-inclusive resorts can also be detrimental to the local economy of the country you are visiting. These resorts take away business from the local vendors who often rely on tourism for revenue. All-inclusive hotels are usually located far from the business centers, making it difficult for visitors to access and patronize these local businesses. At both of the places where I stayed, small vendors selling crafts, t-shirts, and jewelry came to our hotels and set up tables for their merchandise to be seen and purchased. In Cozumel, taxi service was always available, and the downtown market was only about ten minutes and seven dollars away. In Jamaica, however, we ventured out of the resort only once to visit Dunn's Fall, and on our journey, traveling via taxi, we were shocked at the visible poverty that has stricken the country. It can be a culture shock to venture from your seemingly beautiful and exuberant hotel to see what the country is actually like and how the local people live.
For those of you that want to be more conscious when planning a trip but do enjoy the benefits that an all-inclusive package can provide, try contacting the resort prior to booking to find out the percentage of their employees that are from the local community. Other questions to ask can be where does the food served in the resort come from, i.e. local farmers or import; who owns the resort; what they contribute to the local economy; how far the resort is located from local business centers; and the gratuity etiquette. While the hotel may employee local community members, their salaries are often minimal, and what might seem like a modest tip to you could be seen as a generous source of additional income to the employee. All-inclusive vacations can be great but we should all do our part to make sure that our vacations are making both our lives and the lives of those people we meet while traveling better.Have you ever stayed at an all-inclusive resort?
Post a Comment
- Back to tripcrazed's Tripcrazed Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in tripcrazed's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)














Comments (10)
When we're traveling for pleasure we try to include at least one day of community service as part of our vacation. I contact local agencies to see where we can be the most helpful. If nothing else we spend a day picking up trash from a park or roadside. I like to take my neices and nephews to some really nice resorts but like you said I don't want them to lose touch with the community around the resort... When we can we stay in private homes or smaller hotels in an effort to see more of the 'real' community we are visiting.
i have and it was the best experience ever until i left the resort and checked out the rest of puerto vallarta and i saw the poverty. i would recommend leaving the resort and checking out the country as well.
the resort was fun, but it was just that, a resort.
It's illegal to sleep in your car!?!? That's ridiculous. But then again, it is NJ, we have all sorts of ridculous, victimless crimes. I almost got fined for having a camp fire...ON MY PROPERTY!!!
As for all inclusives, no I've never stayed. I prefer hostels or areas that are "inside" of a culture, instead of a microcosm of where I'm getting away from.
yeah, whenever we go to a caribbean location we tend to stay at all-inclusive resorts. when i was little it was great fun! all we wanted to do was swim and run around. but as i got older i liked them less and less, because i realized i was basically seeing only the part of the island where american culture had been imported, and thus all the resorts seemed the same after a while, and also it was negative for the actual community
Never have but I will
I stayed at an all-inclusive resort in the Dominican Republic and I must admit, it was an amazing time. It was great to know that we didn't have to worry about getting our money out everytime we wanted something to eat or drink. We did take a day trip to the captial, Santo Domingo, which was not included in the price. I understand how these resorts drag the economy down in the country itself but it is nice to know that they have ways of getting people out from the resort to see what the country really is like. It's definitely an eye-opener! I highly recommend doing the all-inclusive resort though anytime it is an option. So much easier and less stressful!
I will.
not yet, but I want too...I will look into one for my next vacation.
It's great if you want to relax and get away from it all but in terms of learning about the local culture and all that? Definitely not.
I don't like the concept of the 'all inclusive' in part because that type plan tends to keep 'guests' fairly isolated from the realities of the local populations. And what else is the point of visiting 'other' places if not to experience something of what the locals are like and how they live?
And actually having to dig in your pocket and pay for things as you go supports the concept of learning local values -- monetary ones, at least. Other values, it takes longer to learn than most vacationers have to devoted to the study thereof.
BTW, I just (this morning) returned from a brief visit to the Bahamas where I was only able to get the barest glimpse of local culture, and I felt my visit was way less than satisfactory as a result.
I will be blogging about various aspects of that trip (including some experiences in Florida) within a few days.
doug